Suggestions on how to handle

loaders

Site Supporter
Feb 26, 2008
3,728
4,685
113
30
I am reaching out to my colleagues on this site for their opinion regarding an on going freight claim. Carrier has accepted liability and has offered to pay for the damaged goods. We extended to them the opportunity to transport the replacement freight, so as to reduce the total cost of the claim. They refused, claiming that the freight was too dangerous, not loaded properly, etc. etc. We found this strange, as they had on previous occasions, transported the same freight without complaint, problems or incident. As a result, we had to source alternate transport which was completed entirely without incident. We have sent the carrier an invoice for this transportation cost which they ar now refusing to pay. We have explained repeatedly that the freight claim is made up of repairs or replacement of the damaged goods, AND the costs involved in transporting them to the receiver. Our team has even offered to split this transportation cost in an effort to maintain a good relationship with this carrier. Much to my chagrin I might add. This is what can happen unfortunately, when a carrier decides to act as their own insurance claims adjuster. In closing, what we have done is short paid their invoice by the agreed amount of the damaged freight plus 50% of the transportation costs for the replacement parts. In my grumpy, curmudgeon opinion, a more than fair and equitable solution. In addition, this carrier has been removed from our list of approved companies.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Phantom T
Was the original transport fees claimed and paid by the carrier?
They submitted their invoice and then they agreed to reduce it by the amount of the damaged goods. That’s fine, they decided on their own not to put this claim through their insurance. They are now refusing to pay the costs involved in transporting the replacement product, in spite of the fact that transporting the replacement products is a part of the total claim.
 
Maybe I'm mistaken but "transporting the replacement products" is never tied in with a claim. If the product was damaged, was it refused by the receiver? if so where did the product go next? was it destroyed? who handled that?

We had a claim earlier this year and it went through an adjuster, at no point was "transporting the replacement products" part of the claim. Value of goods lost/damaged and accessorial charges were agreed upon and paid out. The replacement shipment was an entirely different movement, which our customer still paid to "transport".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aeriga
Maybe I'm mistaken but "transporting the replacement products" is never tied in with a claim. If the product was damaged, was it refused by the receiver? if so where did the product go next? was it destroyed? who handled that?

We had a claim earlier this year and it went through an adjuster, at no point was "transporting the replacement products" part of the claim. Value of goods lost/damaged and accessorial charges were agreed upon and paid out. The replacement shipment was an entirely different movement, which our customer still paid to "transport".
Think of it this way. You are hired to transport 6 eggs from California to Toronto. Upon arrival in Toronto, the receiver unloads the shipment of 6 eggs and lo and behold, 2 are damaged. Shells busted, yolks broken, a real runny mess. The receiver signs your BL noting that 2 of the six eggs are damaged. He then files a claim your your firm for 2 broken eggs. You are offered the “ salvage” but who wants broken eggs? The customer supplies invoices for his cost of the 2 eggs to you. In the meantime, he has paid you for the transport of 6 eggs, and he has paid his supplier for 6 eggs.After you pay him for the two damaged eggs, he will still be out for the cost of bringing the 2 eggs out of California. Remember, these eggs were damaged while under your care and control. The customer must be made “whole” and the transport of replacement goods, in this case 2 eggs, is definitely a part of the total claim. Why should the customer have to pay twice for the same shipment? Or an even better example…an entire truckload of eggs. Customer pays you for the transport of a load of eggs he can’t use, and then you expect him to pay again for a second load? The freight charges involved in the failed load are a part of the claim.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Phantom T
Usually, claim related, the original transport charge can be claimed.
But claiming the transport for the replacement product....don't think it has anything to do with the claim.
1 transport = 1 claim including the transport fees.

Never heard of claiming the second transport. Might happen but never heard this.

Also, I would take the same decision, not transporting the replacement. Claim on one, might have another claim on the other one so I would not take a chance.
 
Usually, claim related, the original transport charge can be claimed.
But claiming the transport for the replacement product....don't think it has anything to do with the claim.
1 transport = 1 claim including the transport fees.

Never heard of claiming the second transport. Might happen but never heard this.

Also, I would take the same decision, not transporting the replacement. Claim on one, might have another claim on the other one so I would not
That’s correct. The carrier is responsible to reimburse the customer not only for the damaged goods, but ALSO for the freight charges involved with the damaged shipment, the “failed” shipment. That credit is then used to ship the replacement parts required to make the customer “whole”. In this particular case, the carrier is willing to reduce his original freight invoice by the amount required to repair the damage he caused, but is not willing pay to have the required parts shipped. As I mentioned, he was offered the opportunity to haul them, but refused for whatever reason, that’s fine, his call. We paid someone else and that cost should also come off of the original carriers freight invoice as it is a part of the claim. Cost to repair/replaced damaged goods + original freight costs = total cost of claim.
 
Last edited:
Um...
If we were using your 6 egg shipment with 2 damaged. Isn't the transport portion of the claim 1/3 of the original transport invoice? Unfortunately, it probably won't be enough dollars that you can ship the remaining 2 eggs LTL, but I thought that was the correct math for this claim?

Keep well,
Mike
 
  • Like
Reactions: loaders
Um...
If we were using your 6 egg shipment with 2 damaged. Isn't the transport portion of the claim 1/3 of the original transport invoice? Unfortunately, it probably won't be enough dollars that you can ship the remaining 2 eggs LTL, but I though that was the correct math for this claim?

Keep well,
Mike
The freight portion of this claim (2 eggs) would be whatever is required to get those replacement eggs back to the receiver. So the claim should be: cost of 2 eggs + cost to get them to Toronto. Customer pays the carrier his entire freight bill, plus customer pays his supplier for all 6 eggs. In order to make the customer “whole” , the freight claim is cost of 2 eggs and cost of transport of those eggs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MikeJr
Well, I get your point but, and that's my honest opinion - it's 2 differents shipments. Therefore, if one is claimed, there is nothing that's obligating the carrier to retake the replacement freight transport. As it's 2 different situations.
IMO and always with respect. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: MLCAR
Well, I get your point but, and that's my honest opinion - it's 2 differents shipments. Therefore, if one is claimed, there is nothing that's obligating the carrier to retake the replacement freight transport. As it's 2 different situations.
IMO and always with respect. :)
And therein lies the problem. The carrier is NOT asking for his original freight bill to be paid. He wants us to deduct all of the costs required to finalize the claim from his invoice….fine. However he is balking at the cost to ship the parts required to do so. The original freight bill exceeds the cost of repairs, and he wants to handle the claim, not submitting it to his insurer. There is only I shipment. The first one was never “completed” due to the fact there was damage.
 
Out of curiosity, which freight brokerage do you represent?
Out of curiosity, which freight brokerage do you represent?
Honestly, I really don’t see why that is relevant. There are a number of members on this site who are aware of who I am and the company I own, and I really prefer to keep it that way. As we all know, freight claims are a part of our industry. We all strive to minimize their occurrence as they can have a direct negative influence on the bottom line. However, even the best carpenter hits his thumb on occasion. In retrospect, in this case we should have dismissed the carriers request to handle this legitimate freight claim and filed it directly with his insurer. At least that way, it would be handled knowledgeably and professionally. We would have prepared the claim, including all of the costs associated with it. We also would have paid the carrier his entire original freight invoice. The result would be that our client would receive their due compensation for all the costs involved, damages, shipping, storage, inspection and whatever else they were out of pocket. In this case, trying to be a “nice guy” and work with the carrier to resolve the problem was a mistake.
 
Maybe I'm mistaken but "transporting the replacement products" is never tied in with a claim. If the product was damaged, was it refused by the receiver? if so where did the product go next? was it destroyed? who handled that?

We had a claim earlier this year and it went through an adjuster, at no point was "transporting the replacement products" part of the claim. Value of goods lost/damaged and accessorial charges were agreed upon and paid out. The replacement shipment was an entirely different movement, which our customer still paid to "transport".
Agreed, transporting the replacement shouldn't be part of the agreement if they have sorted out the claim.
 
Agreed, transporting the replacement shouldn't be part of the agreement if they have sorted out the claim.
Just like the cost involved in repairing/replacing the damaged goods, the cost to get the those repaired/replaced goods to the receiver, is a legitimate part of the claim. The customer paid an original freight charge to get his goods. He didn’t get those goods because they were damaged, but he still paid the freight bill. They are not obligated to pay a second freight bill to receive the goods that have already been paid for. Nobody pays the same bill twice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phantom T
It isn't paid twice, initial freight bill is paid back under the original claim. Replacement shipment is a new transport, paid separately.

From what I'm reading looks like the carrier didn't want the claim on their record and tried to pay out of pocket. You did the 'Nice" thing and tried to accommodate but carrier probably didn't realize the extent of a claim to be paid out.
 
It isn't paid twice, initial freight bill is paid back under the original claim. Replacement shipment is a new transport, paid separately.

From what I'm reading looks like the carrier didn't want the claim on their record and tried to pay out of pocket. You did the 'Nice" thing and tried to accommodate but carrier probably didn't realize the extent of a claim to be paid out.
Now you’re getting the picture. Of course, in a regular freight claim scenario, the owner of the goods submits his cost to replace/ repair the damaged goods, along with what he paid the carrier for the original transportation. If that is paid, then the customer can arrange his own freight for the repaired/replaced goods. Let’s say you just delivered a full load to Chicago. The receiver called and said, “listen, 2 of the skids are really banged up, but I think we can fix them here, if we can get the parts shipped to us from the shipper back in Canada.” As the carrier, you could A) load the two damaged skids back on your truck and return them to the shipper in Canada, knowing that eventually they will have to be shipped back to Chicago, or B) leave the skids in Chicago and get the parts shipped down? What option are you picking? What is going to be the least expensive option.? Either way, your customer is going to pay you your original freight bill. However, when the customer is preparing his claim, what amount is he claiming for freight? The full load rate that he paid you, or a portion that more accurately represents the freight cost for two skids? And yes, this carrier was not interested in putting this claim through his insurer. Our mistake was agreeing to go along with that. We should have, and from now on we will, file the claim with the insurer we have on record so that even if the carrier insists on paying out of his pocket, we will hopefully have some recourse if things go sideways, as they have here.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MLCAR
I used to ship hot tubs - at $2 a/lb that's no bueno when these things cost 7k+
we also had additional insurance later on but prior to that the steps I had to take were these

-Shipment damaged - noted on POD and photos asap to notify the carrier of damage as quickly as possible
-file the claim paperwork (their or mine if they don't have)
-Manufacturing receipts for the item
-if repairable an invoice for the repair + any supplies needed for repair
-freight costs incurred - to get it wherever it needed to go + a return to our facility.

Then we would bother them once a week and just keep going until it was paid out eventually.

Most customers were from Home Depot and it was going to a residential address so they aren't paying the freight on it at all. If we had to ship another to that address I likely wouldn't use the same carrier out of fear it would be damaged again (things happen of course so dependent on how often that carrier was used or reputation) to reship was on our dime, but ideally we got something back from the claim, where we weren't whole but that's just the cost of business, mitigate your costs as best you can. A damaged product would likely be repaired and sold as a scratch and dent model at a lower cost.

Later on we got UPS insurance on all the freight that every day at the end of the day we had to declare what was shipped. If there was an issue we would file a claim on there, and they would pay it out and we wouldn't even involve the carrier other than telling them and declaring damage.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MLCAR
Maybe I'm mistaken but "transporting the replacement products" is never tied in with a claim. If the product was damaged, was it refused by the receiver? if so where did the product go next? was it destroyed? who handled that?

We had a claim earlier this year and it went through an adjuster, at no point was "transporting the replacement products" part of the claim. Value of goods lost/damaged and accessorial charges were agreed upon and paid out. The replacement shipment was an entirely different movement, which our customer still paid to "transport".
Replacement freight costs are recoverable assuming the original freight costs are paid in full by the client to you and you to the actual carrier involved. The responsibility is to ensure the customer is made whole. No more, no less. Them paying freight twice on one theoretical shipment does not accomplish that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: loaders