I know certain accounts have huge margins ($1,000.00+) just because they literally need a 24/7 team managing everything. Some people were also lucky enough to lock in crazy rates last year with lazy or uninformed logistics/procurement managers. But that's gross anyways, I agree that it's rare that a broker can NET $1,000.00. Still not going to stop the O/O or dispatcher from complaining about it.
But I digress.
Transportation has become a commodity. Your truck and trailer is no different than hundreds of your other competitors that are running back and forth on the 401. Maybe carriers need to start focusing on the intangibles. Are you answering your phone calls? Are you responding to emails quickly? Are you making your customer's (shipper or broker) life easy? I've observed that even the most basic customer service skills are completely absent at times. Smile when you pickup the fucking phone and never, ever ever ever ever ever ever hang up the phone before the customer. Train your drivers to say good morning to the shipper or receiver. Just basic stuff. Sometimes you'll have a bad day, maybe you'll forget to respond to an email because you got caught up. Then do this: acknowledge it, apologize, and try to improve next time.
This stuff applies to brokers as well, respect your carrier. I don't care how well you pay on the load, if you sound like a dick on the phone, you're still going to be a last option when I'm really desperate. There are brokers I don't even want to work with just because I don't want to interact with them.
Treat your customers like, wait for it, customers (shippers OR brokers). If they value the commodity and level of service you provide, you will have an easy time. You will grow, people will treat you good, and most importantly people will respect you. I'm a small carrier, but I've worked with the same drivers for the last 3 years and I've worked with the same shippers and brokers for the last 3 years. SO if you're still picking up the phone and the first thing that comes out of your mouth is "DISPATCH!!!!!", I'm coming for your customer.
My years in the corporate world, many disciplines, have taught me one thing:
If you can make the life of the person above you easy, they will reciprocate. If not, fuck them and move on.