Most Imaginative Excuses

Funny how turbos, computers and other critical components always seem to fail as far away from a well equipped repair facility as possible. Or the parts warehouse can't seem to find and ship out the new part in any kind of timely fashion. Honestly, I know and can appreciate how expensive and frustrating repairs of any kind can be when they have to be completed on the road. However, the mechanical breakdown excuse is just too simple and easy to use when the cause of the delay is most probably poor scheduling.

It may be a simple and easy to use excuse but if you fear that it is ask the carrier to provide you with the repair facility location/phone number and confirm it. You can also ask for the repair bill. Any reputable carrier will understand why you're making the request.

Sometimes the excuses cannot be helped because the correct information is not there. The fact is repair shops are backed up. We have had Freightliner and Peterbilt shops, especially in the US, tell us that their first available date is more than a week out. Our major last repair, at a Freightliner in Little Rock, AR, took 2 days to get the truck into the shop which we thought was bad enough. Turned out that the diagnosis was either the injector and/or the unit pump. We waited 3 days to get the parts from Memphis which was supposed to be overnighted and they shipped wrong parts. They took all day to replace the parts and we had the same issue. They then took another day and diagnosed it was possibly the cam shaft so the unit pump had to come off again. The next day they did the work and confirmed it was not the cam shaft so they put it all back together and told me that there was nothing that they could do at the time. A bunch of phone calls later and another day we got them to assign a different tech to it who found a pinched wire going to the injector which was probably the issue all along. The pinched wire probably happened when they changed an EGR valve the month before.

Needless to say, eight days of downtime, driver in the hotel wanting compensation because its not his fault, makes you want to pull your hair out - especially when it turned out to be a wire that needed to be cut and spliced. We were lucky we could manage a different truck to deadhead there empty from a previous delivery to rescue the load and have it delivered without issue for our customer.

The repair facilities are not the same as they used to be. Nobody carries parts anymore and the supply chain to get those parts where they are needed is diminished. Technicians have itemized diagnostic steps and manuals to troubleshoot and are not trained to look for simple issues. We are held ransom until the bill is paid and you can argue all you want but the $9,800 US to fix that wire is a serious kick in the seat.

I don't know what I would have told my customer if I had no choice but to stay on this load because the story kept changing. I probably would have given the name and number of the service manger and said 'have fun-I'm not'.

My rant for the day...
 
Here is the glitch in asking a carrier for a phone number for a repair shop. Repair shops are so unreliable and so slow at getting trucks back on the road again, that there are many instances when it is easier/more economical/better all around for the an owner operator to do any many repairs themselves. You can't always back up your story with a phone call to a shop. I have known quite a few owner-operators to spend a day or two looking for that "pinched wire" or whatever other small problem that causes a catastrophic consequence rather than to take the truck to a shop and pay thousands of dollars to find it. It's just not economically feasible for an owner operator to pay for shop repairs on trucks anymore. But I can tell you without a question of doubt, if any broker or partner carrier receives a phone call from me saying we have a mechanical breakdown, they know 100% it is true. That is when trust comes into play. If they know me to be a person of my word, they know a breakdown is a breakdown.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hauling_ass
, if any broker or partner carrier receives a phone call from me saying we have a mechanical breakdown, they know 100% it is true. That is when trust comes into play. If they know me to be a person of my word, they know a breakdown is a breakdown.

I agree with you. I hope my customers feel the same way about us. We will drive hundreds of miles out of route before we tell the customer that we had a failure and if not, we'll have the correct information to back it up.

As for the Owner Operators, I agree as well. Some of them are excellent, and some...well.....
In our case it was a company driver who is far from a mechanic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chica123
From my perspective ... if I tell you why my truck is late, or why I have to give you the load back, you can bet 100% that I'm telling you the truth, no matter how ridiculous the reason may sound. If you're questioning my sincerity, we have no further need of doing business together.
As for the phone number for the repair shop, it's hard enough to get shops to work with you as it is. The last thing I need is a load broker calling the service department every 20 minutes to find out if the truck is fixed yet. Not a good idea to piss off the guy or girl you are trying to get to do you a favour.

@Jim L ... I can top your repair story ... 2012 Pete with an MX engine ... Missoula, Montana had the entire DPF system replaced. Billings, Montana, had 90% of the DEF system replaced. Hagersville, Ontario, had the remaining 10% of the DEF system replaced, ECM reprogram, back pressure valve replaced, and an additional ECM update. Total downtime ... 12 days. Total damage ... just a touch over $16,000.00.
Cause ... 36% idling time !!!

Just a heads up to MX engine owners ... Paccar will practically guarantee major engine, DPF, and DEF problems when you hit 30% idling time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hauling_ass
Good to know Michael. Thanks for sharing that information about the MX engines. Much appreciated!
 
Okay, this one is totally bizarre:
Broker says that they are cancelling the truck because the company won't take a truck on Mondays. Really? Funny how the shipper had told me that it was no problem.
Why not just tell us that they can get it covered for cheaper? Give us the opportunity to either match the lower price or walk away. Jeesh!
 
  • Like
Reactions: martinetav
Drivers and carriers aren't the only ones with excuses ... Best excuse ever ...
"Yes we have your invoice and all the POD's, but my customer hasn't paid me yet, so I can't pay you."

Brings light to the new acronym that goes along with DPF and DEF ... DNU
 
  • Like
Reactions: hauling_ass
From my perspective ... if I tell you why my truck is late, or why I have to give you the load back, you can bet 100% that I'm telling you the truth, no matter how ridiculous the reason may sound. If you're questioning my sincerity, we have no further need of doing business together.
As for the phone number for the repair shop, it's hard enough to get shops to work with you as it is. The last thing I need is a load broker calling the service department every 20 minutes to find out if the truck is fixed yet. Not a good idea to piss off the guy or girl you are trying to get to do you a favour.

@Jim L ... I can top your repair story ... 2012 Pete with an MX engine ... Missoula, Montana had the entire DPF system replaced. Billings, Montana, had 90% of the DEF system replaced. Hagersville, Ontario, had the remaining 10% of the DEF system replaced, ECM reprogram, back pressure valve replaced, and an additional ECM update. Total downtime ... 12 days. Total damage ... just a touch over $16,000.00.
Cause ... 36% idling time !!!

Just a heads up to MX engine owners ... Paccar will practically guarantee major engine, DPF, and DEF problems when you hit 30% idling time.

We have 3 - 2012 Pete's with MX engines - all have the same problem and it isn't because of idling the truck. as we have drivers with very little idling percentages. The last engine update seems to have helped a bit. We sent all our trucks in for a top set, DPF filter cleanout and complete sensor/wiring check. We haven't had a check engine light in 2 months. The longest time the check light has been out before that was usually 2 weeks.
 
We have discovered that, since its introduction, each evolution of the MX engine has been getting better and better. It is our experience that early on the problem is wiring. More specifically, wiring harnesses that are too short. With the advent of multiplexing, wire diameters have been getting smaller and smaller, and they simply won't stand the flexing that is inherent with a truck that actually works all day every day. Might have been great on the test track, and running back and forth between Texas and southern California, but it sure didn't work up here.
 
It was my experience 25+years ago when I operated trucks, and is certainly still my impression today, that no OEM has been able to adequately address the unique operating environment we have in Canada. As Michael mentioned, components that perform well in warmer climates perform marginally at best north of the 49th parallel. I assume it just boils down to numbers, they sell many more units in the US than here and as a result, their focus remains on that market. Imagine being able to operate a fleet that does not have to be plugged in at night from October to May and where antifreeze is only used to help prevent boil-overs! To say nothing about operating on heaving, pot holed roads as well.
 
At one time, and this is probably going back 20+ years, you used to be able to buy a Western Star that was spec'd specifically for Canada ... it was like double the price of a lower 48 truck ... LOL